It is considered good, safe practice to store mason jars holding food with the rings (aka bands, aka screw bands, aka rims) off.
Note this topic applies to sealed mason jars with food in them on a shelf at room temperature. For fridge storage of a partially-used condiment or jar of pickles, you will want the ring on to hold the lid in place.
- 1 Who says you should take the canning rings off?
- 2 Why should you removing the canning rings after the jars are sealed?
- 3 Similar systems
- 4 What do you do exactly?
- 5 The fear of storing jars without canning rings
- 6 The confusion
- 7 The middle road
- 8 This advice does not apply to
- 9 How to store your canning rings when not in use?
- 10 History of the recommendation
- 11 Further reading
Who says you should take the canning rings off?
Note that while removing the canning rings on sealed jars has become a firm commandment in some canning circles, it’s still considered optional by many professionals in the field.
The National Center for Home Food Preservation says,
You can remove screw bands after the food has cooled if the lids are sealed.” 1
The USDA says,
Screw bands are not needed on stored jars. They can be removed easily after jars are cooled.” 2
Even the pros will disagree amongst themselves on this, though. The National Center for Home Food Preservation says elsewhere that the canning rings should be removed:
After canning, screw bands should be removed once the jars have sealed, instead of leaving them on the jars during storage.” 3
And, here’s what Ball Canning says:
A: We recommend storing your jars with the bands off.
(1) If there is moisture in your band, they can start to rust and it becomes very difficult to get those off.
(2) Another reason is that you have food that maybe has gotten under that band, around the neck, you get get some mould, grossness growing on it, and maybe you happened to underprocess your recipe, maybe you got busy with something else and distracted in the kitchen and you think you are done processing and you take it out and let it cool and then a few weeks later it starts to spoil, then you won’t really know that right away if you have your band on your jar. If you store your jars without the band and you happen to have spoilage, the bacteria and the microorganisms that are eating all that smorgasboard of deliciousness in your jar, they are going to create a lot of gasses and they are going to cause that lid to actually come unsealed.
You’re going to smell that, especially with the bands off, you’re gonna know that something is not quite right which will obviously get you into your pantry or root cellar to figure out which jar it is and dispose of it properly. Another great thing about not storing with the band is again if there’s moisture you don’t need to worry about it being rusted and being that much more difficult to get off, and the third reason, which is one of my favourites, is that you have your band available for your next canning adventure … so it’s really a matter of personal preference, we just recommend without. 4
Advice given in their HarvestPro Sauce Maker book (2016) would seem to indicate that some people at Ball at least are moving more firmly to the canning rings being removed. “Jars should be stored without the bands.”5
Why should you removing the canning rings after the jars are sealed?
The USDA Complete Guide (2015) gives two reasons:
- “You can more easily detect some types of spoilage in jars stored without screw bands. Growth of spoilage bacteria and yeast produces gas which pressurizes the food, swells lids, and breaks jar seals. As each stored jar is selected for use, examine its lid for tightness and vacuum.” 6
- “If left on stored jars, [screw bands] become difficult to remove, often rust, and may not work properly again. 7
In short, they are saying that you don’t want the canning ring artificially holding the lid down. The only real true, safe seal is a vacuum (aka hermetic) seal. Don’t rely on a tightened canning ring to hold the lid pressed down; it’s not a true and safe seal; it’s a false seal.
If bacteria starts to grow inside the jars, you want the lids to blow off with no canning ring falsely holding them in place; you want to see that there is a problem before you eat it or gift the jar to someone.
This by the way is the same principle behind the Weck and Fowlers Vacola preserving jar systems, which both use clamps instead of a screw-on ring band to hold the lid on during processing.
The Weck people say,
In case the contents of a jar should spoil for any reason (for example, as described in Case 2) the gases formed by spoilage inside the jar must be free to push up the lid so that it lies loosely on top of the jar. This warning signal is so clear and strikingly plain that it is best suited to protect you and your family from the dangers of consuming spoiled canned food unknowingly. For this extremely important reason of personal safety, a reason which is still more important than the practical ones mentioned above, WECK has consistently refused to produce jars with mechanical wire bail seals for home-canning purposes. In case of spoilage, these mechanical seals cannot produce the strikingly clear warning signal of the loose lid.” 8
It is particularly important to remove the canning rings with alternative lid closure systems such as Tattler lids, which don’t ping or become depressed as they seal. You need to check physically that you have a seal by removing the canning ring and inspecting the lid.
Fowlers Vacola says that the clamp (which they call a clip) is removed once a seal is assured: “The Preserving Clip is an integral part of the preserving process, as it holds the lid in place during the process, whilst allowing air to be expelled from the bottle, creating a vacuum seal. Clips are only removed 12-18 hours following completion of preserving process, once vacuum seal is secured. ”9
After you remove the clamps, for either Weck or Vacola jars, you would verify that you indeed got a vacuum seal, then wash your jars, label and date them, and store them away.
What do you do exactly?
- After removing jars from the canner, let them sit undisturbed for 12 to 24 hours. “Do not retighten bands after processing since this may break the seal that is forming.” 10. (The only exception is when using original Tattler lids, which require a quick tightening after being removed from the canner, but after that leave them alone.)
- Remove the rings, check that the lid has sealed.
- Whatever you do, even if you do want to store your rings with the ring on, still do the above step to ensure that you got seals. Don’t put jars away without checking the seal, and to do that, the rings must come off.
- Wipe down the jars and lid, let dry, then date and label and store jars.
- Wash rings, dry and store (tip: you can put them in cutlery basket of dishwasher to wash them, though the abrasiveness of dishwashers may shorten the life span of the rings.)
Note that you cannot process your jars without the rings on. You must have the rings on during processing to hold the lids down. But after processing, the rings have done their job for now — their work is over until the next jars are ready to be canned.
The fear of storing jars without canning rings
A writer for Backwoods Home Magazine says don’t be afraid to take those canning rings off afterward:
Some people fear that if they remove the ring, the jar will come unsealed and the food ruined. This is not true. If the jar is properly sealed, removing the ring never lets the seal come undone.” 11
If the lid comes off while you are removing the ring, you never had a true seal to begin with and the food in the jar may not be safe, so you want to know right away.
Some people are worried that without the rings, a bump is more likely to weaken the seal between the lid and the jar. Others reply that if the seal was that weak, there was a problem to start with.
When transporting jars, or posting them, some people prefer to put the rings back on just in case.
The Kerr company, though, who invented the two-piece metal lid system, has said in the past that it’s unnecessary to put the rings back on at all: “Can jars of home canned foods sealed with the KERR Mason Cap be moved or transported for several miles? Yes. The handling or shaking of the jars during transportation will not cause the seal on the KERR Mason Cap to release even though the screw bands have been removed.” 12
People get confused because they see so many photos of canned goods with the rings on, even on knowledgeable canning sites and in photos appearing in books from trusted sources such as Ball, etc.
The reason the rings are on for the photos is simply because the jar can be more photogenic with a ring on: it hides any food that may have boiled and crusted onto the inside rim of the jar neck, and gives the jar overall a more gem-like appearance.
The middle road
Some people do a middle road: after removing the rings, checking the seal and cleaning the jars, they put the rings back on very loosely: they feel that that way, problem lids will still pop, but that they have the rings to protect the lids from inadvertent bumps, etc.
Just before opening a jar, lift it gently a few inches by the lid rim (without the canning ring on.) That way, if your mind is absent and the lid seems to come off just a little bit more easily than usual while you are popping it open, you will at least know that the seal actually was good, and that you just got lucky with an easier-opening jar that time.
This advice does not apply to
- Mason jars just used as storage jars to hold dry foods. In this case, a ring is needed to keep the lid on and moisture and pests out;
- Opened or unsealed jars holding moist food in the fridge. In this case, a ring is needed to keep the lid on and some air out so the food product will last longer in the fridge.
How to store your canning rings when not in use?
See our page with ideas about how to store your canning rings when not in use.
History of the recommendation
The recommendation to remove the canning rings goes back to at least the 1980s.
In June 1986, Dr Gerald Kuhn, who pioneered the first USDA Complete Guide, was quoted in an article advising the practice:
We’re making a big effort to say: remove the ringband before you store jars,” [Dr Gerald] Kuhn said. “Then, if the lids become loose, it may well be an indication that the product underwent spoilage, swelled, and broke the seal of the lid. A loose lid is an indication that the product is now unsafe to eat.”13
Marisa McClellan. Why You Should Store Your Jars Without Their Rings. 31 October 2013.
Sharon Peterson. Storing Home Canning Jars, Rings on or off? 30 September 2014.
United States Department of Agriculture (USDA). 2015. Complete guide to home canning. Agriculture information bulletin No. 539. Page 1-16 ↩
Ball HarvestPro Sauce Maker Recipe Guide. 2016. Page 21. ↩
United States Department of Agriculture (USDA). 2015. Complete guide to home canning. Agriculture information bulletin No. 539. Page 1-20 ↩
Ibid. Page 1-20 ↩
https://weckjars.com/facts.php. Accessed May 2015 ↩
Jenkins, Kathryn. New guidebook available this fall giving up-to-date home canning tips. Frederick, Maryland: The Frederick News-Post. 19 June 1986. Page F-1. ↩