Some home canning recipes for tomato-based products have started calling for the tomatoes to be roasted as part of the prep.
The process works best with large, paste-type tomatoes such as Roma, San Marzano, and Amish Paste, etc, but it can also be done with other tomatoes.
The roasting both concentrates the juices and caramelizes the sugars in the tomatoes, providing amazing flavour. The resulting sauce will also be a darker sauce, more wine-coloured than a bright red. It also causes the skins to separate themselves from the tomato flesh of their own accord, making them far easier to peel than the boiling-water blanch method does.
There’s also a reasonable chance that roasting the tomatoes is one of the more or most energy efficient way of reducing tomatoes for sauce because modern ovens are very well insulated. As a result, the heating element isn’t actually running all the time, only cycling on and off as needed to maintain the temperature you told it to.
There is no need to spray or oil the baking trays. In fact, don’t. Oil should never be added to home canning recipes unless a tested recipe specifies its addition, as oil can impact heat penetration during the canning process.
- NO oil or cooking spray
- Using a paring knife or other tool of your choice, cut out the cores of the tomatoes, then slice them in half vertically.
- Place cut-side down on ungreased, rimmed baking sheet.
- Roast for 45 to 50 minutes at 225 C (450 F).
- Let cool (see note below about freeing up baking sheet.)
- When cool, leaving the tomatoes lying flat, proceed to simply pinch the skins off them by pinching towards the centre. If skin isn't coming off the tomatoes effortlessly, they needed to be roasted longer.
- Collect skinned tomato halves.
- Flick off any hard black carbonated bits on them from the pan (soft charred roasted pieces are fine to leave,)
- Discard any liquid left on the tray (or refrigerate in a tub for use with crushed tomatoes, juice, etc.) You don't want that in the sauce, it will make it watery.
- Pass through a sieve or food mill for a smooth sauce. Or whiz through a food processor for a rustic, chunkier sauce with seeds. (The recipe you are following will advise.)
- After repeated rounds, you will get some juices burning to black on your baking trays, particular on the sides and in the corners. When the time comes for clean-up, you can get rid of this black burnt stuff easily by simply pouring boiling hot water from the kettle into the pan, and letting it soak 20 to 30 minutes. It will dissolve off with no effort required from you.
- Make sure you use baking sheets with rims at least 2 cm (1/2 inch) high or higher, as a lot of juice will free up and you don’t want that running off into the oven.
- Don’t make mistake of tipping hot tomatoes off the baking tray all into one bowl; you will have a heck of a time afterward trying to fish the skins out of that gloopy mess. Instead, leave tomatoes on the baking sheet to cool. However, if you only have a few suitable baking sheets (as is the case for most of us, probably), and need to free up a baking sheet for the next roasting round, use a spatula / flipper to lift the tomatoes off and lay them out on a platter or plates in single layers.
- Discard skins, or, dry for pulverizing into a tomato powder for garnishes, etc.
- Anyone with a dual oven will be very happy to have one.
Can you use the oven roasting technique for peeling instead of blanching?
To be clear, we want to address this point.
We have seen no discussion from reputable sources on the matter of doing oven roasting instead of water blanching as part of tomato prep. For instance, in prepping tomatoes for the USDA spaghetti sauce recipes, etc.
So we have no advice to pass on in this matter.
We will, however, supply you with a list of tested recipes from reputable sources that do call for this technique, which should be enough to keep you busy for the near future.
If you are wondering about applying this technique to recipes other than the ones listed below, you will need to contact the source responsible for the recipe you are looking at.
Here is a list of tested recipes drawing upon oven-roasted tomatoes.
Hearty Pasta Sauce (HarvestPro Sauce Maker Manual, 2016, page 6)
Oven-roasted marinara sauce (Ball All New, page 204)
Roasted tomato guajillo sauce (Ball All New, page 174)
Salsa roja (Ball All New, page 166)
Roasted Eggplant and Pepper Putanesca Sauce (Ball All New, page 181)
Roasted Roma Tomatoes (Ball Blue Book, 37th editon, 2014. Page 33)
Salsa Ranchera (Ball All New, page 176)